Get Free Download  7 French Secrets to Staying Sexy! 

Get Free Download  7 French Secrets to Staying Sexy! 

WHEN THE QUESTION WASN’T CLEAR, GUESSING THE RIGHT ANSWER EXPOSED THE TRUTH

May 16, 2019 3 Comments

Monique Olmer Beautiful at 98

“Why am I here?” my mother asked me when I was visiting her at the nursing home.

I explained that since she wasn’t able to walk anymore, she needed help and this was the best place. She thought about my answer and replied, “Yes, this is a nice place, but why am I here?” Thinking maybe she hadn’t understood, I tried to explain it a bit differently, the point being that she was no longer able to live on her own. She looked away nodding that, yes, she knew that, but I could tell she was still pondering her question.

A little while later she looked at me and with more determination and said, “I don’t understand why I am not home. Pépé and Mémé (my grand parents) were living at home.” I wasn’t certain what to say, so I didn’t say anything. She continued: “Francis (her husband, my father) was at home also. I just don’t understand why I’m here.” Her look was contemplative and concerned.

I understood her question and her anxiety. She had envisioned the end of her life in her home, as it had been for her parents and my father, so a nursing home wasn’t part of it.

I didn’t want to use her impairments as an explanation again; that was clearly not giving her the answer she was searching for. So instead I changed the subject and hoped that the distraction would alleviate her angst and it did for a while.

But again, she asked me directly, “Why am I here? I don’t understand.”

At this point I replied with the only thought that popped into my head. “Well you know you’re ninety-nine, Mom.”

“I’m ninety-nine,” she repeated. “That explains everything!” Her face brightened as she repeated to herself “I’m ninety-nine,” a smile filling her face. I was relieved and a bit surprised that that was the answer that explained her predicament.

A few times during the afternoon she looked at me and repeated, “I’m ninety-nine.” I even overheard her on the telephone with one of her grandchildren saying, “You know I’m ninety-nine” with certainty and resolve in her voice.

Her reaction made me laugh; it was charming. Her age was the explanation she needed. It wasn’t that she didn’t know how old she was, but it was hearing the truth of her age in that context that allowed her to understand that she had outlived everyone she knew, as well as the expectations she had for her own life.

Answering my mother’s question and easing her mind was hard since I didn’t actually know what she was asking me. As it turned out, I said what seemed like the most obvious thing and it worked. What was evident to me wasn’t for her, since she was trying to understand her life as she imagined it should be, not as it actually was.

My experience with my mother has made me wonder how often we do the same thing; that is, try to explain our lives by how we think they should be instead of how they actually are. If my mother’s example teaches us anything, it is that our lives might be easier to understand if we let go of how we think our lives should be and just accept how they are.

What about you?

Have you ever found that your perception of how things are supposed to happen gets in the way of how life actually is?

I’d love to know.

Merci 

 

Want more:

Here is a blog post you might also enjoy reading. When Perception and Reality Differ—How Do We Know What’s True

 Here is the link to the post Click Here





3 Responses

Adeline Olmer
Adeline Olmer

May 24, 2019

Diane – Thank you for your comment. I do not think any part of this process is easy or simple, it differs with everyone. My description of my experience with my mother was one story that I found enlightening and charming and expressed something that made me think, that is why I shared it. -A

Lisa – I so agree with you that understanding each other’s viewpoints is part of all our lives every day. It is a challenge but one that can only help us communicate in a way that we can comprehend and empathize with each other. Thanks -A

Diane
Diane

May 24, 2019

Having just gone through this with my mother, I find this to be a gross oversimplification.

LIsa Manuele
LIsa Manuele

May 17, 2019

The subject you have brought forth is relative to everything in life. Seeing “what is” as opposed to what you want or think it should be is a challenge for all of us. We rationalize and then believe ourselves. It happens every day as people look at us and we look at them and our viewpoints are our own in either direction. It’s about individual perception.

Arguments, Wars, misunderstandings, conflicts of all kinds are rooted in perception. Thinking from both directions is an art form. We all need to adopt it more often.

Having an elderly parent in a situation they had not envisioned and now are in is heartbreaking. I hope the acceptance of age stays with Mom

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in Blog

Russian Wedding What I expected vs what actually happened French-secrets.com
WHAT I EXPECTED VS WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED

June 19, 2019 1 Comment

An acquaintance invited us to his daughter’s wedding, a traditional Russian wedding in Brighton Beach, Brooklyn. When we arrived it was dark—it was closed. I checked the invitation to confirm the date, the location, the time; everything was correct—there was no one! I said, “This is ridiculous, let’s…

View full article →

When NO doesn't really mean NO, cultural differences
WHEN NO DOESN’T REALLY MEAN NO.

June 13, 2019

One of the disagreements my husband, Mark, and I have is that I do not use the word NO the same way he does. I use it as it is used in France—NON, meaning: oh really, let’s talk about that; you’re going to have to convince me.... Mark understands no to mean no you are wrong. He can say...

View full article →

The American Cemetery in Normandy
WHAT ARE WE WILLING TO DO FOR FREEDOM?

June 07, 2019 2 Comments

As we celebrate the 75th anniversary of D’ Day… Thinking about the magnitude of what occurred… I discovered that there is a huge difference between seeing movies or reading about WWII and actually being there... At the museum, I found myself in front of the Jewish star, the yellow star that every Jew had to wear. I was mesmerized and overcome by…

 

 

View full article →